Intentionality and the objects of thought › How the Two Volumes Fit Together
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Intentionality and the objects of thought › How the Two Volumes Fit TogetherSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
In the opening volume, the validity of an inference survives a person's failure to recognize it. In the final investigations, Husserl asks what it takes for a person to recognize that something is as they have judged it to be. To see the connection, imagine a student who can repeat the statement about a triangle's altitudes and point out an instance drawn on the page. That already displays different ways of relating to the statement. To see why the claim holds generally, the student must understand what in the proof warrants the conclusion. A good drawing can direct attention to relevant features. The claim concerns all triangles of the stipulated kind, including ones that look quite different from this drawing. Prolegomena, §§6–8, 21–23 · Investigation I, §§9–12
One question remains pressing. If all our encounters with meanings are singular events, what entitles us to say that we grasped the same meaning twice? The book responds by distinguishing what changes from what remains identifiable across occasions. I may first hear someone's words and later put the same claim in writing. Each act has a place in my history. I can still compare the inscribed sentence with what I took the speaker to have said and ask whether I got it right. That everyday possibility motivates Husserl's account, even for a reader who wishes to question how he describes ideal meanings. Investigation I, §§11–12, 30–32
This explains why the discussion of consciousness belongs in a book that starts with logic. Husserl's descriptions examine how a claim can be understood, how someone can encounter what it concerns, and how the encounter can justify believing it. Questions about which mental events brought someone to a judgment are still open to psychological study. The investigation of validity and the investigation of how validity is grasped give a reader separate questions to ask the next time an argument seems convincing. Investigations, introduction · Investigation VI, §§6–11
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!