Intentionality and the objects of thought › The Arguments Against Psychologism
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Intentionality and the objects of thought › The Arguments Against PsychologismSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
One argument concerns what warrants each kind of law. A psychological generalization is supported by observations and rests on induction. Even a law stated in exact terms in an empirical science draws its warrant as a claim about the world from evidence available up to that point. A pure logical law, for Husserl, is exact and warrants a different kind of insight. An observed counterexample to the claim that students invariably reason in a particular way could alter that claim. An observed mistake would leave open the question of what follows from their premises, and the fact that it counts as a mistake requires such a question. Prolegomena, §§21–23
A second distinction is between the judgment as an event and what is judged. In his discussion of relativism, Husserl takes the claim that two times two equals four. One person's act of judging it occurs at a certain time and may have been prompted by something a teacher said. A second person can judge the same thing for a different reason. The two events have different histories. Each can nevertheless be a judgment of the same content. The claim can be correct without inheriting a time of origin from either act. Prolegomena, §§23–24, 36
Husserl presses the issue against the idea that truth itself depends on the constitution of a species. Differences in how two species arrive at judgments would be entirely intelligible. Even their useful methods of calculation could differ. The trouble arises when they are supposed to affirm and deny one and the same claim and both be correct on account of what species they happen to belong to. That is stronger than saying they see different things or use words differently. Husserl argues that calling both judgments true in the same sense changes the meaning of truth while still relying on that meaning to advance the thesis. One of his tests is to suppose that there were no truths. The very claim that there are no truths would then have to be true. The argument concerns what is being claimed, quite apart from whether a particular relativist can be persuaded to change their mind. Prolegomena, §§35–36, 46
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!