Intentionality and the objects of thought › The Turn to Meaning
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Intentionality and the objects of thought › The Turn to MeaningSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
If the same proposition can be judged on different occasions, how do we recognize what stays the same? Husserl begins the first investigation by considering how words work as signs. Smoke can indicate a fire because taking in the smoke gives you a reason to suspect that something is burning. Someone can also use the words the fire is out to express a claim. In conversation the words do two things at once. They convey a meaning about the fire, and they can indicate to the listener that the speaker has had some relevant experience or formed a judgment. A person silently rehearsing the sentence can still express the same thought to themselves, without using the words as evidence of a speaker's state of mind. Investigation I, §§1–4, 7–9
Husserl uses a geometry example. When a teacher says the three altitude lines of a nondegenerate Euclidean triangle meet at a point, a listener may learn that the teacher judges this to be so. That point can lie outside the triangle. The geometrical assertion is about the triangle. It can be repeated by another teacher and remain the same assertion even if the voice, the language, or the surrounding circumstances change. Its meaning also differs from what it is about. A geometer might reach the same point by reasoning about angles and by reasoning about intersections. Distinguishing the point, the ways it is specified, and the occasions on which it is thought gives the analysis more to work with than a general reference to the idea in someone's head. Investigation I, §§11–12
Meaning accordingly allows for a range of cases. The word triangle can be understood without a picture of a particular triangle accompanying the thought. A picture, if one occurs, has a determinate size and shape. What is meant by the word may apply just as well to a figure with different sides. The same difference appears when the words can be understood even though we may be unable to find an object that answers to them. Husserl considers the golden mountain as an example of a meaningful expression for which no existing object need be found. Investigation I, §§12–15, and II, §§1–5
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!