Names and necessity › An identity discovered in the sky
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Names and necessity › An identity discovered in the skySection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 9 ↓
“Hesperus” and “Phosphorus” are names for the same object, Venus, introduced in connection with evening and morning appearances. The observations by which people learned that the two appearances were of the same body were empirical. Use the two names with their actual reference and ask whether there could be a situation in which Hesperus and Phosphorus are two different objects. Kripke's answer is that both rigidly pick out Venus and that Venus cannot be distinct from itself. The identity, if true, is necessary. Whether the two names have the same bearer is something people had to discover. Naming and Necessity, lecture II, pp. 100–105.
You can imagine having much the same evidence while observing two different celestial bodies. This would give you a situation in which observers might introduce two names by the same methods and succeed in naming different objects. It remains a distinct possibility from the one Kripke denies, in which the two actual names, interpreted as we use them, name Venus and Venus turns out to be distinct from Venus. The example separates what the evidence could have left open for an inquirer from what could have happened to the object. Kripke treats the first as a question about knowledge and the second as a question about necessity. Naming and Necessity, lecture II, pp. 102–105.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!