Names and necessity › How a name reaches someone who never met its bearer
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Names and necessity › How a name reaches someone who never met its bearerSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 9 ↓
An alternative picture begins with an act of naming. Someone can name an object by pointing to it, or fix the reference of a name through a description. Other people can learn the name and pass it to others. They need not have met its bearer or be able to provide a description unique to that person. They can intend to use the name for the same person as the people they learned it from. A student who remembers just a little about Gödel can use the name through the history of that practice. The teacher and the student can have different beliefs and refer to the same person. Naming and Necessity, lecture II, pp. 90–97.
A merely causal connection can also be present when reference changes. A person may hear an account of Napoleon and decide to name a pet “Napoleon.” This introduces a separate use through an intentional change. More complicated cases can occur without the users realizing that reference has shifted. In the book's addenda Kripke discusses Gareth Evans's example involving “Madagascar.” In the reported origin story, a name for a place on the African mainland was applied to the island by someone who took himself to be preserving the earlier use. The example concerns what a shift like that would imply for the picture. The argument does not require the details of the origin story to be established. Naming and Necessity, lecture II, pp. 96–97, and addenda, pp. 162–164.
For this reason Kripke describes the account as a sketch. Intending to preserve a use and being connected to an earlier use do substantial work in the examples. A complete account would have to explain which links carry the reference, when a descriptive assignment can establish it, and when later use overtakes earlier history. Even so, the contrast with the view under criticism is clear enough to test. The person who learns a name can refer successfully without first working out a uniquely identifying description of its bearer. Naming and Necessity, lecture II, pp. 91–97.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!