Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Following a Sample
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Following a SampleSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 9 ↓
Picture a person learning the word by pointing to a glass. Their words concern the liquid, rather than its container or its temperature. They also take the sample to stand for the same kind of liquid as other samples people around them call water. This is an assumption that can be wrong. Putnam's illustration imagines that the sample unexpectedly turns out to be gin. We have reason to revise our judgment about the sample instead of using it to redefine every instance of water. The Meaning of ‘Meaning’, pp. 5–6 of the MIT excerpt
The example shows why visual resemblance is insufficient in the proposed account. What matters for the term's application is whether further instances are of the relevant kind, and that may take investigation. Early users of the word might sort everyday samples very successfully while having a mistaken view of a test that would distinguish the kind. In Putnam's scenario a later discovery about the liquid can correct a judgment about a sample without constituting an arbitrary change in what earlier speakers were talking about.
Expertise is a related but distinct issue. Putnam also imagines an exchange with a community whose use of the term “aluminum” concerns what ours calls molybdenum. He supposes, for the sake of the example, that a nonexpert cannot ordinarily distinguish items made of the two materials, while a metallurgist can. A speaker can use a word that applies to a kind without personally being able to perform the distinguishing test. The 1750 case adds a different point. It asks how extensions could differ even before the relevant ability to discriminate is available within the communities. Explaining the water example solely by appeal to experts who already know the formula would miss that point. The Meaning of ‘Meaning’, pp. 6–8 of the MIT excerpt
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!