Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › What the Argument Does and Does Not Settle

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated October 13, 20262 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 7 of 12Mind, Self, and Experience
Chapter 82Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › What the Argument Does and Does Not Settle
Reading section 7 of 9 · What the Argument Does and Does Not Settle · 2 minSection 7 of 9 · 2 min

Section 7 of 9 · 2 min read

Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › What the Argument Does and Does Not SettleSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 9 ↓

A critic can grant that the two terms have different extensions and still ask how much follows about what a speaker understands. Oscar and Twin Oscar may both associate the word with an ordinary clear liquid. Perhaps those shared expectations explain why they talk and reason in parallel. That leaves an external component in any account of which substance their words apply to. It raises the further question of whether that component is part of what we should call meaning or something a theory of meaning must connect to.

The worry can also be pressed against the example's verdict itself. Why say that the speakers' terms concern different kinds instead of saying that both use a term broad enough to cover whichever liquid behaves in the familiar way? Putnam's answer relies on a feature of the kind term as he understands it. Ordinary recognition supplies evidence for applying it, while belonging to the same kind as the relevant samples takes priority when evidence of a difference comes in. A critic can contest that priority. This identifies a point of disagreement more exactly than treating the imagined planet as though it were a laboratory experiment that confirmed a general theory of language.

Nothing requires us to apply that answer to every expression. Consider “clear liquid.” Two chemically different substances can both fall under that description if they are clear and liquid in the circumstances. The water example makes its point by distinguishing such a description from putatively naming a kind. The example's conclusion would be much weaker if every description of an object were already a name for whatever chemical substance happens to be present.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy