Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Two Communities Saying “Water”
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Two Communities Saying “Water”Section view · Sections in this chapter5 / 9 ↓
In The Meaning of ‘Meaning’, pp. 4–6 of the MIT excerpt, Putnam imagines Twin Earth. In the story there is a liquid that resembles the water we use in ordinary conditions. Twin Earth speakers call it “water,” and it plays the same familiar role in their surroundings. Its chemical composition, abbreviated XYZ, is different from H₂O. The resemblance is part of the setup. We are not meant to conclude that such a liquid has been discovered.
Putnam then sets the comparison around 1750. The speakers in his imagined case do not know the composition of either liquid. Oscar on Earth and his counterpart can match one another in their inward experience, thoughts and expectations while learning the word from different samples. Setting the example before the relevant chemical knowledge matters. If the speakers knew the chemistry and explicitly meant different compounds, it would be easy to find a difference in what each knew. Putnam is asking us to keep that knowledge fixed and vary what the word has been used to identify in each environment.
What should we say about the extension of the word? Putnam thinks the Earth speaker's use applies to water and the Twin Earth speaker's use applies to the different liquid that occupies the corresponding place in their environment. The difference turns on the actual substances, although the speakers do not yet know how to tell those substances apart. The argument relies on holding fixed a suitably narrow description of each speaker's psychological state. If we build which external substance a belief is about into our description of that state, we have already allowed the sort of external difference the example is designed to bring out.
The extension of a term in a particular use consists of the things it applies to. Putnam's Twin Earth argument concerns how that extension gets fixed. It leaves room to distinguish a term's extension from what a speaker knows or ordinarily associates with the term.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!