Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Reading the Two Arguments Together

Michael BrenndoerferUpdated October 13, 20262 min read
PhilosophyAll chapters
Reading tools Notes & comments
Notes & comments
Part 7 of 12Mind, Self, and Experience
Chapter 82Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Reading the Two Arguments Together
Reading section 8 of 9 · Reading the Two Arguments Together · 2 minSection 8 of 9 · 2 min

Section 8 of 9 · 2 min read

Mental roles and the world beyond the mind › Reading the Two Arguments TogetherSection view · Sections in this chapter8 / 9 ↓

Place the examples side by side. In the pain case an identity theory insists on the same physical and chemical realization where Putnam thinks a common functional role might be enough. In Twin Earth a theory of extension insists that a narrow psychological description is enough where Putnam thinks the historical use of different substances makes a difference. He changes what information counts as relevant because the questions ask about different properties.

An account of how two speakers respond to words, remember their earlier encounters, and revise their expectations can tell us a great deal about why their behavior matches. It can still leave out which liquid they have been identifying. It would take another argument to show that no functional description can include relations with a surrounding world. The water case challenges the narrower assumption that what happens inside the individual already fixes the extension of the term.

This leaves us with a practical way to compare explanations. When two cases share a label, ask what must be held fixed for the label to continue to apply. For a proposed account of pain, the answer might be an organization of states and inputs that different physical systems share. For a word used to pick out a natural kind, one thing to check is the sample history or surrounding practice that gives the use its object. Putnam's arguments give reasons for placing those boundaries differently, and they make it possible to say where a critic would have to disagree.

Comments

Add to the conversation

A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

Newsletter

Stay up to date

Get new articles, book updates, and notes on AI and technology.

Unsubscribe at any time. Privacy policy