Mind and category mistakes › A Test for Reading or Teaching
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Mind and category mistakes › A Test for Reading or TeachingSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
Take the statement “She understands the rule.” It is easy to feel that we must either locate an inner act of understanding or settle for recording what she did. Ryle's framework gives us more to look at. Ask the student to explain where the rule comes from, apply it to a new case, or recognize when it is irrelevant. Each request samples a different way a competence can show itself. One successful response can be rehearsed, and one failed response can reflect an ambiguous question. Together, responses in suitably different circumstances give a teacher more to go on. We can make this test without pretending that everything important about a learner's experience is visible to us. Chapter II, §§2–3, 6, and 8–9
The same exercise helps with philosophical theories. When a theory proposes an additional event to explain what a person did, ask what independent work the event is supposed to do. If the theory treats an intelligent move as the product of a prior intelligent consultation, try applying its criterion of intelligence to the consultation itself. If a concept is instead being used to describe an ability, ask how one could tell what counts as success, accident, or error. These questions return us to the visitor at the university. There was something real to understand about the institution, and the last stop on the tour was never going to supply it.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!