Mind and category mistakes › Recognizing Skill Without Watching a Second Performance
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Mind and category mistakes › Recognizing Skill Without Watching a Second PerformanceSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
Consider Ryle's clown. An ordinary stumble and a practiced fall can resemble one another closely. The practiced fall may hinge on where the spectators are looking, when they expect the performer to regain balance, and whether the performer can fall again safely on cue. We learn to describe what the clown did by attending to those circumstances and to what the performer is capable of doing. A camera can record the stumble. The competence is not a separate event of the sort that another camera angle could reveal. The recorded fall can be an exercise of it. Chapter II, §4, “The Motives of the Intellectualist Legend”
This also explains why a single observation can mislead. A novice may accidentally do the right thing. A practiced performer may make a mistake. What happened matters, and so do the reasons for it, the conditions under which it was done, and how the person handles a change in those conditions. Suppose a learner tests a proof on two simple examples and finds that it seems to work. A teacher can ask the learner to produce a case in which one premise fails, or to explain why the next step still follows when a diagram is redrawn. Those questions help distinguish remembering a route through a familiar example from being able to work with the argument.
A competence can survive interruptions and change its mode of exercise. A chess player knows how to play while asleep. When she wakes, she may demonstrate that competence by making a move, identifying a blunder in someone else's play, or explaining a line she would choose under a different rule. These possibilities clarify why a description of a skill cannot be read simply as a prediction that a given movement will follow a fixed cue. The player has to be responsive to circumstances. One choice can display that ability even if it would have been a mistake in a slightly different position. Chapter II, §6, “The Positive Account of Knowing How”
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!