Mind and category mistakes › What a Category Mistake Changes
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Mind and category mistakes › What a Category Mistake ChangesSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
The visitor to the university could have made a mundane error. He might have asked for the library and been pointed toward the registrar's office. A map could have corrected that mistake because the library is the kind of place for which that question makes sense. But his request to see the university as one more institution alongside all the others has a different structure. He has placed the university in the same list as its constituent establishments. Giving him more addresses would not explain how those establishments are related.
Ryle brings out another version of the confusion with team spirit. Someone watching a cricket match might understand what the bowlers, batters, fielders, and officials do, yet ask whose separate job it is to supply the team's spirit. An explanation might draw the spectator's attention to how people carry out their own tasks, support one another, and respond when a teammate makes an error. Those observations can matter even when they fail to identify a further player. In the example, the trouble lies in the spectator's expectation about what counts as an answer. Chapter I, §2
A category mistake occurs when a question or description presupposes the wrong logical type. Searching for team spirit as a separate position in the lineup is one kind of mistake. Misidentifying a player who actually occupies a position is another. Learning a player's name could settle the second case while leaving the first confusion untouched.
Applied to the mind, the proposal needs care. The examples show that words can describe real features of a situation without naming a separate item of the kind a puzzled spectator is looking for. They also show how treating a description as the name of a separate item can generate an apparently deep mystery about its whereabouts. By themselves they cannot establish that every mental description behaves like university or team spirit. Ryle has to make the case for his specific target by studying psychological descriptions and the circumstances in which people use them. This is where his treatment of intelligent action earns its place in the book.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!