Community and the person who chooses › Rawls's Later Distinction
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Community and the person who chooses › Rawls's Later DistinctionSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
In “Justice as Fairness: Political, Not Metaphysical”, published in 1985, Rawls distinguishes a citizen's public identity from an account of all the ends and attachments that matter in their life. The original position is a way to represent fair relations among citizens. Its artificial description does not provide a theory of the essence of human persons. A citizen can undergo a deep change in belief and retain the same standing in public institutions. The theory's ability to describe that continuity does not require saying that the change meant little to the citizen.
That response narrows the issue. The relevant question is how far political justification can draw only on a conception of people as citizens. Sandel's closing chapter added for the second edition explicitly returns to the revised account in Political Liberalism. It helps to keep the time sequence in view. The book's original critique addresses the conception Sandel finds in A Theory of Justice. The later exchange addresses a political account intended to answer some of the worries raised about that conception. A person could find the representation adequate for deciding terms of legal cooperation while still asking whether it leaves enough room for shared purposes in other parts of public life.
The distinction shows why the dispute cannot be settled simply by pointing out that most people value belonging. Both sides can acknowledge the reality of attachments. The sharper question is what role those attachments can play in assessing the grounds, limits, and priority of justice. If one asks only for a procedure that bars special pleading, some abstraction appears welcome. If the question is why a set of terms counts as the terms of a shared undertaking, the excluded material may matter again. The point of the exchange is to say which question is being asked and what conception of a person the answer needs.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!