Community and the person who chooses › What an Agreement Can Establish
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Community and the person who chooses › What an Agreement Can EstablishSection view · Sections in this chapter5 / 8 ↓
Sandel raises another question in chapter 3, “Contract Theory and Justification”. Even if the parties in the original position would pick the principles Rawls describes, why does that make the principles just? With an actual promise, a person's act can help explain why they have an obligation they previously lacked. Nobody has made such a promise in the original position. The justification needs another account of why the considerations allowed in the hypothetical choice are the appropriate ones.
Rawls can answer that the original position is an attempt to represent fairness, and that it can be tested alongside considered judgments. The method of reflective equilibrium lets a philosopher revise the description of the choice, a general principle, or a judgment about a case when they no longer fit. The hypothetical choice is then part of an argument with several moving parts. The question Sandel presses is how the contract and that mutual adjustment relate to each other. If considered judgments already supply some of the reason for describing the choice as fair, the agreement does not provide a foundation entirely independent of them.
An everyday example helps separate the issues. A neighborhood council says it has imagined what participants would choose if none knew their own address. That removes an obvious source of favoritism. It may still matter whether people need the bus to reach work, whether some have limited mobility, and whether the service is already unequally distributed. An appropriate description of the choice would establish which considerations can enter it, but that appropriateness is itself open to argument. The agreement that follows cannot settle every dispute over how the question was posed.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!