Community and the person who chooses › Who Chooses in the Original Position?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Community and the person who chooses › Who Chooses in the Original Position?Section view · Sections in this chapter3 / 8 ↓
In A Theory of Justice, §§3–4 and 24, Rawls imagines parties choosing principles for the basic structure of a society under fair restrictions. The parties do not know their particular social place, talents, or aims. They have general information, and they can reason about goods useful in many plans of life. The agreement is hypothetical. Its purpose is to bring out which reasons would count if no one could design the basic rules around a position they knew to be theirs.
The parties are choosing principles for institutions. They are not choosing a religion or family or deciding what their whole life will mean. Sandel's question is what makes their choice an appropriate representation of people for that particular task. If each person's claims can be adequately represented by putting their ends to one side, it may look as though the person could always be identified independently of the ends. Sandel argues that this possibility matters to the priority Rawls gives to justice. It determines what the parties can present as a claim that another person ought to take into account.
The distinction between the hypothetical procedure and the people it represents is especially important here. Abstracting from a fact during a decision does not establish that the fact has no bearing on a person's identity. People can sit on a jury without bringing their personal relationships into the judgment. They do not have to stop being the people those relationships help make them. A defense of Rawls can make an analogous point. Sandel's objection has to show that an abstraction useful for one purpose carries consequences that are too strong for the political theory.
Rawls gives the parties reasons to care about primary goods. It would be a mistake to attribute to him the view that they have no information or motivations at all. The harder question is whether the particular standpoint available to them models enough about citizens for the claims of justice. A basic liberty can protect people with many ends. To establish that this protection is enough, one still has to know which interests or forms of agency could be affected by the rule.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!