Community and the person who chooses › What It Means for the Right to Have Priority
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Community and the person who chooses › What It Means for the Right to Have PrioritySection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
Imagine citizens with different views about whether a religious practice, a profession, or political involvement makes a life go well. They need rules about how a government treats them, and those rules may protect their freedom to pursue different ends. On the liberal view Sandel describes in the Introduction, the rightness of the basic terms of cooperation is independent of assuming any one of those particular goods as the end of society. The principles give people a framework within which to pursue their aims. A gain in aggregate satisfaction need not justify a departure from those principles.
The distinction matters in a case where one form of life is popular. A majority might want institutions to favor it because they believe that wider adoption would be good for the whole society. A defender of the priority of the right can ask what entitles this majority to use public coercion to advance that end. The value the majority finds in the end does not decide the issue. The freedom of those who do not share it is itself part of what must be secured.
Sandel's first chapter asks how Rawls can make justice primary in this way. He is concerned with the place justice has in the theory as much as the particular principles selected. Even someone sympathetic to equal rights can ask whether all political reasoning about their justification can proceed independently of the ends by which people understand themselves. This is an argument about what a defense of rights needs to include.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!