Comparing actual injustices › The Ideal and the Choices Available to Us
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Comparing actual injustices › The Ideal and the Choices Available to UsSection view · Sections in this chapter2 / 8 ↓
Sen uses transcendental institutionalism for an approach that makes two choices about its subject. It looks for the institutions of a fully just society, and it concentrates on the just arrangement of institutions. He associates the approach with a tradition of social contract thought that includes John Rawls. The Introduction, pp. 5–8, distinguishes that project from comparative approaches that ask how feasible alternatives differ in justice.
It is worth separating two objections. One concerns the feasibility of identifying a uniquely just system. There can be several reasons for justice that survive examination even when they point in different directions. The flute illustrates the obstacle. The other objection concerns whether a unique ideal, even if we could identify one, would settle comparisons among imperfect alternatives. Sen's painting example, pp. 15–16, asks us to imagine that the Mona Lisa is the best painting in the world. That judgment leaves open which of two other paintings we should prefer. An account of the best thing does not automatically supply a way of measuring distance from it.
The same problem can arise in assessing an institution. Consider two ways to give children access to school. One makes travel easier for people far from a school. The other improves the safety of the buildings children already reach. Knowing what a school system looks like with excellent buildings and reliable transport need not tell us which change to make first. The comparison depends on what is missing in the situation, whose prospects would change, and what harms can actually be avoided under each alternative.
Sen's treatment of Rawls is more specific than a general rejection of institutional design. In chapter 2, “Rawls and Beyond”, he acknowledges what he learned from Rawls while disputing parts of his theory. The basic structure, public reasoning, and the attention paid to freedom continue to matter. The question is whether establishing the rules of an ideally just basic structure has to come before judgments about how available alternatives affect people's lives.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!