Comparing actual injustices › What a Comparison Still Requires
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Comparing actual injustices › What a Comparison Still RequiresSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
One might worry that without a blueprint, comparison simply picks the improvement that looks easiest. Sen's approach still allows reasons to object to the feasible set itself. Suppose two proposals to improve access are being considered, but the people involved know that either can be modified cheaply to reach a third group now excluded. The comparison is altered by finding that possibility. Treating the first two proposals as all that can be done would ignore part of what matters about them.
The new possibility may come from considering the institution's actual operation. There might be a legal rule that can be changed, a pattern of conduct that frustrates its stated purpose, or an existing capacity no one had thought to use. Identifying a remediable injustice requires work on those particulars. It can involve strong principles, such as a commitment to equal public standing, without requiring that every disagreement about the content of perfect justice be resolved at the same time.
The flute gives the other side of the point. We should be ready to consider Anne's, Bob's, and Carla's reasons. Any judgment worth making has to account for facts of ability, deprivation, and labor that are easy to miss from one fixed perspective. Where the reasons converge, a comparison can be decisive. Where they conflict, a theory can show us more precisely what remains at issue. The adjudication is better informed even before we settle it.
The question of feasibility therefore deserves its own scrutiny. What a public authority can do depends in part on which obstacles it regards as fixed. Collective inquiry may show that some of them are arrangements people have the capacity to change.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!