Comparing actual injustices › The Three Claims to a Flute
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Comparing actual injustices › The Three Claims to a FluteSection view · Sections in this chapter1 / 8 ↓
Anne is the only child of the three who can play the flute. Bob has no toys of his own, while the other two have some. Carla made the flute and wants to keep what she has made. Each has a reason to claim it, and none of the three denies the facts on which the others rely. It would be easy to say what to do if only one of those claims were before us. The difficulty is that we have to consider all three at once.
This is Amartya Sen's example in the Introduction to The Idea of Justice, pp. 12–15. Anne appeals to what can be done with the instrument. Bob's claim concerns deprivation. Carla appeals to her work in making it. Each reason can be offered on behalf of any child in the same position, so impartiality alone need not select one. We can scrutinize the claims and may come to a judgment. The force of the case is that a unique answer cannot simply be assumed because the parties have left favoritism behind.
Sen first published the book in 2009. Its Preface starts from the force of injustices we have reason to think can be removed. The flute presents a problem about the grounds of judgment. The book asks how those grounds can guide comparisons between options when people continue to disagree about justice. It also asks which features of people's actual lives a comparison ought to consider.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!