Comparing actual injustices › The Point of Hearing From Elsewhere
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Comparing actual injustices › The Point of Hearing From ElsewhereSection view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Chapter 6, “Closed and Open Impartiality” draws on Adam Smith's impartial spectator to distinguish open from closed impartiality. A procedure can ask members of a defined group to set aside their personal advantage while limiting whose perspectives enter the inquiry. Open impartiality asks us to test a judgment in the light of perspectives that may come from outside that group. Such perspectives can bring into view harms to other people or assumptions those within the group have learned to take for granted.
Imagine a school board weighing a change in class hours. Board members might ignore their personal schedules and still share a narrow picture of how children get to school. Hearing from people who work later shifts or provide care across different households can expose facts the board did not know. A neighboring district that tried a different arrangement might reveal an assumption that needs testing. Those outside perspectives do not automatically decide what the school board should do. They enlarge the evidence and reasoning by which its choice can be assessed.
The point is related to Sen's emphasis on democracy as public reasoning. Counting votes can determine which option wins under a rule. Public reasoning also affects which options people put forward, what evidence the voters can consider, and whether the people affected can challenge the terms of the choice. A decision can be improved through that prior work even if the final voting procedure stays the same.
An open discussion can produce disagreement that is harder to resolve than the earlier consensus. This need not be a defect. If the previous agreement depended on overlooking a harm, discovering the harm makes the problem more visible. There may then be reasons shared across the new disagreement that support an immediate change. There may be other reasons to examine further. The aim is to make a better comparison of the alternatives, including better alternatives that would never have entered the discussion under its earlier terms.
The reach of the discussion can matter across borders as well as within a local institution. Suppose one community's proposal will change the use of a shared waterway. If one community considers only its own members' claims, impartial consideration of those claims could leave an upstream or downstream harm out of the account. Someone from elsewhere may also question the method by which the community has decided what counts as a genuine harm. The two contributions are different. In one case, an affected person's interests have been left out. In the other, experience from elsewhere can improve the reasoning even if the person offering it is unaffected.
Sen's contrast between open and closed impartiality also makes it possible to disentangle the boundary of a decision from the boundary of the discussion. A local authority may be legally responsible for a decision. It can nevertheless learn from people who have no vote in its elections. Consulting them could change a decision without creating a new global authority. In the Preface, Sen makes a corresponding point about international public reasoning. The ability to evaluate and challenge a policy across a border matters even in the absence of an institution empowered to settle every dispute about global justice.
A comparison can become more concrete once the perspectives are included. Perhaps one proposal preserves more access upstream while another avoids a serious harm downstream. People might agree to leave out a third proposal that does worse on both fronts. That is already a result of reasoning about justice, though choosing between the first two could require a further judgment. If new information suggests that the harm can be avoided without giving up access, what formerly seemed a difficult tradeoff may no longer be the relevant choice. Openness matters here because it can uncover the alternatives, as well as improve the descriptions of the options first presented.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!