Thinking through categories › How to Read a Transition
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Thinking through categories › How to Read a TransitionSection view · Sections in this chapter7 / 8 ↓
Take one passage with three short entries on a page: what the current category says, what becomes difficult when it is taken in that way, and what the next category adds. If you cannot give the middle entry without borrowing the next category in advance, reread the passage. The objection may be that Hegel has assumed the transition. That is sharper than saying the prose is hard.
For Being and Nothing you can make the test quite precise. Each is supposed to be indeterminate. The proposed successor gives the way they are distinguished a role in the movement instead of assigning each a separate content. A critic can agree that the first two formulations lack a distinguishing determination and still ask why this licenses movement. An empty distinction might instead tell us to stop and reformulate the problem. To decide between these readings, ask what the transition would need to explain that the claim of emptiness alone leaves out. This gives a concrete point of disagreement even before you decide how much of the book's larger ambition to accept.
The same routine applies to the example of measure. Record the description that remains stable through some change, the point at which it no longer does, and the question about persistence that follows. This time the terms are much richer than in the opening, and what counts as an example is correspondingly more constrained. The similarity is in how we read the move: we record what a determination accomplishes and then identify the precise feature that it cannot account for by itself.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!