Thinking through categories › Quality, Quantity, and Measure
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Thinking through categories › Quality, Quantity, and MeasureSection view · Sections in this chapter4 / 8 ↓
With determinate being, a limit can matter to what the thing is. Consider a boundary of a shape. From one point of view it is where the shape ends. From another, the same boundary specifies the shape. This is a useful entry into Hegel's analysis because it makes it harder to treat all limits as obstacles added to something already complete. The illustration does not imply that every determination is a spatial boundary. The related problem of finitude is whether a bounded something can be understood without the other through which its limit is intelligible.
A response to a limit is to point beyond it. But if the beyond gets its meaning entirely from the finite thing it excludes, the finite remains part of the account of the beyond. Each advance can leave another limit to cross. In the discussion of finitude and infinity, especially §§270–303, this helps explain why an endless progression is inadequate as an account of infinity. The progression depends on the contrast between what is finite and what comes after it. Hegel's fuller conception must grasp that dependence within it. His target is a way of understanding their relation. Reading the passage as a claim that a list has a last member would miss the issue.
Quantity introduces a different relation to change. Varying a magnitude can leave a qualitative description in place. The description can also cease to apply when the variation crosses a threshold. To illustrate the relation, imagine warming water under conditions in which it stays liquid over part of the range and subsequently boils. Over the first range the water can warm while remaining liquid. At the onset of boiling, vapor forms within the liquid. What varies, what remains stable, and which conditions are being held fixed all matter to the example.
The section on nodal lines of measure relations, §§769–773, develops the corresponding thought. A series can be continuous in one respect while certain points mark a difference in kind. Hegel's remark following §773 also treats numerical and chemical relations. You need the details of the case to say where a change occurs. The logical point is that stating how much has changed and stating what kind of thing you have can affect one another. In the transition to essence, Hegel asks how something can persist through the alternation between measures. See the final sections of Being and the opening of Essence for the steps between those questions.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!