Individuals and a rational order › Reading the Arguments Together
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Individuals and a rational order › Reading the Arguments TogetherSection view · Sections in this chapter8 / 9 ↓
The difference between expression and knowledge matters here. Saying that Alexander expresses the whole universe does not imply that he can answer every question about it. The complete concept belongs to the account of who Alexander is. What he can distinguish in experience depends on his perspective and his powers of attention. Imagine seeing a crowd from the end of a street. Your impression can depend on all the people in it without your being able to identify every face. This is a limited analogy for how much can be expressed confusedly. It does not explain how a finite individual's concept could include the entire course of the world. That further commitment comes from Leibniz's metaphysics. Discourse, §§9, 33
These arguments set different tasks for explanations. When we ask why Caesar acted, we look at the reasons of the agent and his situation. When we ask why that entire history obtains, Leibniz points to God's choice of one order of things. When we ask why one person's perceptions agree with those of another, the relevant feature is how their distinct histories express that same order. These answers put different weights on the complete concept. It explains why an event belongs to a particular individual, while the choice of a world explains why that individual and these events are actual.
A useful reading exercise is to return to section 13 with the story of Caesar in mind. For each premise, ask whether it is a claim about logical possibility, a description of this actual choice, or a claim about the reasons of an agent. Try doing the same with the argument about Judas in section 30. If a premise about what happens in this world looks necessary, ask what supposition has been held fixed to make it so. Reading the passages in this way helps separate the explanatory power of Leibniz's distinctions from the very strong metaphysical picture he asks us to accept. Discourse, §§13, 30
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!