Individuals and a rational order › The Complete Concept of an Individual
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
Individuals and a rational order › The Complete Concept of an IndividualSection view · Sections in this chapter3 / 9 ↓
The example in section 8 is Alexander the Great. Kingship alone leaves open which king we mean. It does not tell us whether the king conquered Darius or Porus, or what brought about his death. A historian looks for evidence of these things one at a time. An understanding of Alexander's complete concept, of the kind Leibniz attributes to God, would disclose the grounds of every true predicate about Alexander without waiting for those events to happen. The point is stronger than saying that God knows all the events. Leibniz says there is something in the subject's own concept to understand about why these predicates belong to it. Discourse, §8
Think of the difference between a partial description and a full account. “A king who won a battle” leaves open many individuals. Adding the names of the defeated rulers still does not account for everything this person did or underwent. These are useful descriptions even though they leave much unspecified. The complete concept is an ideal of understanding, so the question of how a historian might assemble such a dossier is beside the point. The historian and God need not obtain knowledge in the same way for their judgments to concern the same events.
Alexander's concept is consequently more than a list of traits. Who he fought and what happened to him are truths about him that also involve other people and events. Leibniz pushes this thought very far. Each substance expresses the entire universe from its own standpoint. He compares this to the different views one can get of a single city. A view from the river and a view from above the walls represent the same city, but they make different features easy to see. There is no requirement that one viewer see everything distinctly. This is an analogy for differing expressions of a common world, rather than a claim that each substance has a physical vantage point. Discourse, §9
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!