The subjective character of experience › Could We Describe Experience More Objectively?
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The subjective character of experience › Could We Describe Experience More Objectively?Section view · Sections in this chapter6 / 8 ↓
Near the end, Nagel proposes exploring an objective phenomenology. The aim would be to describe features of experience in terms a being could understand even if it cannot have that experience. If such a project succeeded in part, an investigator might learn more than they can from vague comparisons between the senses. The new description would still have to concern the character of an experience. The purpose is to achieve greater precision without pretending that the viewpoint has ceased to matter. What Is It Like to Be a Bat?, pp. 449–450
Imagine trying to explain two things about the way a sound is perceived. You might convey which parts of a melody are experienced as repeating, even when the listener lacks a way of grasping its precise sound. Or you might describe how a pattern separates into foreground and background as attention shifts. These examples are suggestions about the kind of partial description one could try. They do not establish that the structural relations exhaust what hearing the melody is like. The distinction between specifying one feature and conveying the experience in full is central to Nagel's proposal.
The prospect of partial understanding also helps locate the limit of the bat story. If you can compare two patterns of sonar use, you have some information about the bat's sensory world. If you acquire a way to talk about how those patterns might be organized in experience, perhaps you can understand a further aspect. The bare fact that a human observer can say something informative does not yet settle whether the new descriptions preserve the phenomenon completely or provide an account of its physical nature. It does give us a clearer idea of the work a better theory would have to do.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!