The subjective character of experience › Imagining a Bat's Flight
PhilosophyAll chapters Reading tools Notes & comments
The subjective character of experience › Imagining a Bat's FlightSection view · Sections in this chapter1 / 8 ↓
Try to imagine finding an insect in the dark by sending out a sound and hearing it return. You can invent a scene. Perhaps each echo seems like a point appearing on a map. Perhaps it feels more like hearing something change in pitch. Those are ways for you to make sense of the exercise. How would you tell whether either resembles how the surroundings appear to a bat?
Thomas Nagel uses this difficulty to make his argument concrete in What Is It Like to Be a Bat?, pp. 438–439. You can imagine fitting out a human body with wings or having it move through a dim room. Projecting yourself into the scene answers a question about how life with those movements might appear to you. Nagel wants to understand how a bat's life appears to the bat. The resources of your imagination come in large part from experience you already have. Rearranging that material may leave you with an image that answers the wrong question.
This problem matters even if your interest is human experience. Consider a scientist who can describe everything going on in a human being by using concepts available to observers with very different senses. Can that scientist's description tell us what a person experiences in a way that preserves its character for the person? On Nagel's account, the difficulty lies in understanding how such a description could account for that character at all. For this purpose the bat makes a general puzzle easier to see.
Comments
Add to the conversation
A question, a correction, or an example from your own work.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!